Fabian Hürzeler's quest to kill the orthodoxy

by ROYSTON REEVES

On a cold afternoon in February 1983, sixth-division German side Viktoria Backnang faced the formidable Dynamo Kyiv in a home friendly. The local climate, filtered by the thick, evergreen forests of Baden-Württemberg, was a favourite of physical trainers and therapists. Kyiv, led by their innovative coach Valeriy Lobanovskyi and Ballon D’Or winner Oleh Blokhin, were staying at a training centre nearby and had selected the German side for a warm-up match. The minnows Backnang, meanwhile, fielded a hometown midfielder named Ralf Rangnick. After kick-off, Rangnick became suspicious of his opponents. When the ball went out for a throw-in, he gingerly scanned the pitch and counted the Kyiv players. “I thought, ‘something is wrong,’ he recalled later. “They are playing with thirteen or fourteen men.”

Two years passed and the astute Rangnick became a fully-fledged coach himself, given charge of VfB Stuttgart’s amateur team at just 27. Mystified after counting only eleven Kyiv players on that wintry afternoon, Rangnick had spent the interim years puzzling over the Ukrainians’ extraordinary setup. Having exhausted German football expertise, he enlisted the help of a trained structural engineer named Helmut Groẞ. Rangnick and Groẞ would stay up late into the night devouring, annotating and drafting coaching manuals as they deconstructed the mechanics of Lobanovskyi’s fearsome hydra - and tried to imagine how they might build their own. The pair ordered VHS tapes of Arrigo Sacchi’s Parma and sat watching them over strong coffee, Rangnick’s finger hovering above the pause button. Sacchi had developed Lobanovskyi’s analytical approach into an immensely compact 4-4-2, with a guiding rule that the most advanced player in the team could never be more than 25 metres from the deepest. Sacchi obsessed about dominating space, infamously training his players without the ball, and choreographing perfect geometric unison relative to imaginary opponents.

According to Rangnick, he and Groẞ stopped and rewound those tapes so many times their equipment broke down; there was no short route to un-patterning the choreography he’d witnessed that afternoon in the Black Forest. The fabric had been stitched over decades with a complex blend of mathematics, physical conditioning and tactical geometry, where attacking and defending had been allied to position rather than possession.

Decades on, the managers of the world’s leading clubs are each overlaying that science with their own ideas. Spatial control is en vogue, and ball turnover rates are plummeting in the big leagues. To minimise the risk of losing possession, short, horizontal passing in defensive areas is tactically essential. In the Premier League, defenders like Ezri Konsa, Marc Guehi and Virgil Van Dijk routinely attempt more than 60 passes per 90 minutes. But in the long stretch since Ralf Rangnick sat befuddled by the elegance of positional play, the tactical generation’s vulnerabilities have been exposed.

In that buildup phase, where physical titans manoeuvre the ball laterally in front of the opposition, a timely, choreographed ambush can throw the best intentions into panic. To achieve such a co-ordinated jump, a team needs an attacking unit of remarkably quick-thinking athletes, and a gutsy coach willing to take considered risks. More than forty years after a young Rangnick chose to forgo a playing career to instead untangle football’s most pressing question by video tape, another young German is constructing his own kind of answer.

Securing our future.

Festival is our summer quest to re-ignite SCOUTED ahead of 2026/27 - and to make football writing joyous again.

No clickbait. No garbage. Writing just like this, full of ideas, players and storytelling - great, intentional reading, the way it used to be.

Tony Bloom, one of the world’s most successful sports bettors, is nicknamed The Lizard for his calculated demeanour and creativity with statistics. He has long embraced the nickname: in 2006 Bloom founded Starlizard, a secretive, data-centred betting consultancy. After becoming chairman of Brighton in 2009, Bloom began applying data algorithms to the scouting of footballers. In 2021, his system flagged a young midfielder in the sleepy Los Chillos Valley, Ecuador, playing for a then lesser-known club called Independiente del Valle. Teenage Moises Caicedo had starred in the under-20 Copa Libertadores a year before but had previously suffered a serious knee injury, and there were questions about his psychological readiness for a move to Europe. The ongoing global pandemic, too, presented issues, but the flashing lights on Bloom’s data machine spurred him on, and he parted with just over £4.5m to bring the midfielder directly to the Premier League. The rest of this story is famous. When Tony Bloom makes a bet, the market pays attention.

A year after Caicedo, Bloom welcomed another new arrival: the spiky Italian manager, Roberto De Zerbi. In De Zerbi’s first year he led Brighton to both their highest-ever finish in English football and European qualification with a daring, bait-and-switch counter-attacking system. The Italian’s approach had proven the perfect foil for Bloom’s high-risk Moneyball brief. His style presented midfielders as ‘bouncing walls’ that could bypass frantic presses with deft, vertical touches, and the most striking manifestations of these instructions went viral: images of his centre-backs, predominantly on-loan Levi Colwill, simply standing with their foot on the ball and waiting for the opponents to press for so long it became almost awkward, spread like wildfire. But despite the continued momentum on the pitch, De Zerbi soon grew impatient at the club’s reserved transfer spending. In 2024, he abandoned the project, leaving Bloom in need of a new pioneer. The machine’s lights flashed again. They led to a young manager, just past thirty, who was developing an inventive pressing system at St. Pauli In the port city of Hamburg. Nearly 500 miles from the location of Rangnick’s storied 1980s training base, Fabian Hürzeler was similarly obsessed with history.

Like Rangnick, Hürzeler had been evoking a ghost. Instead of trying to replicate the heavy metal, man-to-man frenzy of Jürgen Klopp’s Liverpool or Marcelo Bielsa’s Athletic Club - two of the most copied pressing systems of the time -  Hürzeler designed a compact block positioned halfway up the field, supplied with zipped, vertical passes from Swedish centre-back Eric Smith. Sacchi’s rigid spatial collectivism had done away with the idea of a Libero, a centre-back with licence to move freely, take risks and spot gaps in the opponent’s shape; Hürzeler had brought it back. Smith would periodically step up from defence into the base of midfield to confuse the opponent’s marking. After drawing pressure towards him, Smith would float weighted passes directly through the lines, slicing away layers of defensive organisation.

Defensively, St. Pauli’s press was not as relentless as Klopp’s. Instead, it would flicker and burst, with forwards awaiting specific, choreographed pattern triggers (a slow, square pass, for example) before aggressively rushing the opponent’s structure, suddenly converging on the clumsy technique of centre-halves. Instead of holding a high defensive line away from their goal, St Pauli would tempt their opponents’ hubris, actively encouraging opposing defenders to express themselves before springing a sudden trap. The opposition defence would lose nerve and scatter the ball to narrow, panicked channels along the touchline - where they would find their passing routes suddenly needle-thin. Hürzeler’s press was more cerebral than Klopp’s, less emotional: more about psychological manipulation than relentless energy. Hürzeler’s team were not athletic superheroes but ugly ducklings and positional misfits, trained with acute spatial discipline: midfield anchorman Jackson Irvine, an Australian international who wore a mullet and pink boots, had spent most of his journeyman career bouncing between the EFL and Scotland; rangy, long-legged wingers Elias Saad and Dapo Afolayan were built more for defensive jockeying than touchline turns.

St. Pauli’s young conductor had turned traditional footballing archetypes upside down, but the Premier League would be the ultimate test of his model. The jump in quality and physicality was obvious, but in England Hürzeler would face adaptable tacticians willing to confound his ideas; he would have to find an approximation of Eric Smith, and his new midfield needed rebuilding after the loss of Caicedo and Alexis Mac Allister. The youngster and The Lizard set to work.

The British media reacted to Hürzeler’s appointment with curiosity. Although he held a growing reputation as a tactician, he was the youngest ever Premier League manager and years shy of many of his own players, including stalwarts James Milner, Danny Welbeck and Lewis Dunk. His first chance to win the public over arrived in a fascinating methodological duel; a tough Premier League away game at Everton. Everton boss Sean Dyche deployed a dense, narrow 4-4-1-1, straight from 1990s Serie A - Hürzeler’s decade of birth. Dyche’s Everton would intentionally relinquish the wings to their opponents, instead instructing wide midfielders Jack Harrison and Dwight McNeil to track back, double up and block off opponent passing lanes. Goodison Park was not a place for visitors to attempt creative nonsense.

Hürzeler turned Dyche’s ploy against him, and set up a system that made Everton’s hard running their downfall. Throughout the first half, he gradually drew his central defenders, Jan Paul van Hecke and Lewis Dunk, deeper and deeper, sucking Everton’s compact unit up the field as they sought to sustain control. But control became increasingly complicated. Brighton’s midfielders would continually cycle positions so Everton’s found themselves outnumbered. Brighton’s wingers, Yankuba Minteh and Kaoru Mitoma, sank into deep, wide areas, dragging Everton’s full-backs away from their centre-halves and opening channels of space. Dyche’s carefully calibrated eight-man block began to resemble Swiss cheese. Brighton ran out 3-0 winners and Dyche left the field fuming. In front of their own fans, the grizzled mastermind and his Grand Old Team had been tactically neutered by a curious German upstart.

As the season progressed, Hürzeler continued shapeshifting, reacting pointedly to his opponent’s ideas. Against aggressive front presses such as Erik ten Hag’s Manchester United, Hürzeler would completely remove one of his midfield pivots and add an extra attacker, belligerent enough to simply set up his orchestra behind the high walls of his illustrious opponent. Wide players like Ferdi Kadioğlu and Jack Hinshelwood would intermittently invert or drop into deeper spaces, making Brighton’s shape impossible to predict. As the team’s rhythm grew, the passive mid-block Hürzeler used to bamboozle Everton evolved into something more assertive, with Brighton earning a reputation for gathering in numbers of six or seven upfield to snatch the ball in dangerous areas. Rather than intently waiting for mistakes, Brighton developed an aggressive wide ‘flytrap’ that would suddenly force rival full-backs into rushed passes in dangerous zones. And just as he had at St. Pauli, Hürzeler positioned a fearless ball-carrying libero as his creative fulcrum - this time the Dutchman Van Hecke, who has since joined Tottenham Hotspur for a reported £52m - to continually break lines and force transitions. Opposition defenders would repeatedly find themselves dazed and flat-footed, with Mitoma or Minteh racing towards them one-on-one.

In less than a year, Hürzeler dismantled De Zerbi’s possession-based identity and replaced it with a model that constantly flexes around the intentions of its opposition. Today, at the end of his second season, the fluid, choreographed system Rangnick once marvelled at has become something wickedly unpredictable. If positional play is conducted like a classical orchestra, then Hürzeler is football’s Beethoven: breaking classical rules and changing speeds to fit the vibration of the moment. “I don’t believe in formations,” Hürzeler once said of his tactical approach. Brighton’s young symphonist prefers to think of the pitch as a series of swirling mechanisms that gradually confuse and exhaust the opposition.

It hasn’t been perfect. Hürzeler has presided over two long slumps in form, one in each season and both beginning in December, and by the middle of 2025/26 his job was seriously in doubt. They recovered both times, and he’s guided Brighton to 8th in successive years - just one place shy of De Zerbi’s record finish. This time, unlike last, they’ll play in the UEFA Conference League. “Every human being has doubts and overthinks when the results aren't there,” Hürzeler said on reflection. “During that period, we stuck to our principles.” Those principles have, largely, won Brighton fans back, although some confusion remains. “At times the subs and tactics have been baffling,” one Brighton fan told BBC Sport; “The constant tinkering and playing players out of position was infuriating,” said another.

But tinkering is the natural form of a young coach determined, like Rangnick, to constantly deconstruct his opponents, and it’s hard to argue with the results. His record against England’s traditional ‘big six’ is remarkable: nine wins, four draws and two defeats from his first fifteen contests. Hürzeler’s rebellion might be the antidote to the stranglehold positional play currently has on the Premier League, and now has Europe in its crosshairs. As this story was nearing publication, Hürzeler gave an interview to The Athletic. “Two things are important in these kinds of phases,” he said, of the difficult winter periods. “Never let these doubts or fear or insecurity impact your behaviour or your belief. It’s very important that you always stand in front of the group and express this belief. And the second thing is: don’t change my deep philosophy. The change would be, ‘Now we go to a low block and we only make transitions’. And that’s the worst thing you can do […] I’m so convinced of my style of playing, my philosophy, I won’t change it. I will adapt and adjust to certain elements. But this deep foundation will always be with me.”

To continue to improve upon his deep foundation, Hürzeler will need to coexist with the star-selling strategy that has funded Brighton’s rise from the third tier of English football. When the time is right, players like Minteh and Carlos Baleba will make lucrative moves to wealthy clubs - Van Hecke already has - and Hürzeler will need a flow of specialist recruits for his squad of high-altitude snipers. Brighton’s search won’t be for relentless sprinters to charge at defenders’ feet or charge from blind spots; the club’s targets are judged more on observational or mental skills: anticipation, adaptability, decisiveness and speed of thought.

Five years from Brighton’s capture of Caicedo, such moves have become vastly harder to make. The kind of thinking and tools Bloom championed during his rise are now widely available and commonly used; Independiente del Valle have one of the most closely watched academies on the planet. The massive windfalls Bloom enjoyed plucking players like Caicedo and Alexis Mac Allister directly from source have inspired similar recruitment amongst others with more resources, like Arsenal’s pre-contract agreement with the Ecuadorian twins Edwin and Holger Quintero earlier this summer, and Manchester United’s capture of Cristian Orozco. In 2017, Bloom’s Starlizard branched out into Jamestown Analytics, a deeply secretive analysis firm (their website is a single, mostly unadorned page) who now influence recruitment across Bloom’s portfolio and beyond.

And so Bloom’s success has perhaps put some players out of his reach. For example, Morocco’s Ayyoub Bouaddi was perhaps the breakthrough star of this summer’s FIFA World Cup. In years past, his intelligent observation of the game and extraordinary eye for an opponent’s structural frailties might have made him an ideal target for Bloom; today, by eighteen, Bouaddi’s transfer value is already far outside Brighton’s upper limit. The wealthiest clubs have begun replicating Bloom’s playbook, and in response he’s re-strategised around his point of advantage: his obsessive young manager with a knack for pulling tactical misfits into high performing harmonies. Hürzeler’s unconventional tactical blueprint has given his club new impetus in the market: the technical, tactical and psychological characteristics required to conduct his plans have narrowed their focus. When coveted centre-half Luka Vuškovic decided to join Brighton in a club-record deal worth over £50m earlier this summer, Hürzeler led a series of direct discussions that tipped the wonderkid’s decision in Brighton’s favour.

He’s also revealed he was involved in deciding upon Vuškovic in the first place. “He’s [Bloom] very open,” Hürzeler said to The Athletic. ”He gives me a lot of freedom, a lot of power. Of course it’s [recruitment] in a frame. What I mean by a frame is: when you need a centre-back, the numbers say we have these four or five choices. Then we sit together. How is his character? Does he fit the style of play? Does he fit into the locker room? And injuries in the past. All these kinds of things, the soft factors. But then it’s always a decision we make together. So, this frame comes from Tony. But within this frame, we have a very transparent and very honest collaboration. I see I can create something together with Tony.”

So far, Bloom and Hürzeler seem a good match, and the frame they’ve built together is working. They each mirror the other: they are both reactive, flexible players of the games they’re dedicated to, acutely aware of their strategic disadvantages and willing to take risks to overcome them. Bloom has zigged as others zagged, and now that everyone is playing his game, he’s moving again. While Hürzeler’s ideas are too young to have caught on as widely, it’s not hard to imagine a tactical future in which his influence is key. Just like Rangnick, poring over tape all those years ago, Hürzeler has written a discordant symphony designed to overthrow the orthodoxy; Tony Bloom has offered him the perfect stage.

We need help to stay alive. If you enjoyed this essay, please consider subscribing from just 67p a week. You'll get a weekly feature essay - just like this one - every single week for 2026/27, a monthly recruitment analysis column, and 20% off all our print magazines. More importantly, you'll help keep an independent publication going, and our writers paid fairly. Thank you.